Annette 3

Held in Common Good

A Matter of Precedents is a research project and resource on the ‘common good’ created by artist, educator, and writer Annette Krauss with producer Frances Stacey and artist researcher Alison Scott. The project has developed over a number of years and has evolved through multiple forms, including; installation, a map, study walks, a web presentation and zines.

Materials shared here include collected, commissioned and gathered information which was brought together through Annette’s research into the status and potential of the ‘common good’. The ‘common good’ is a form of collective property, unique to Scotland, comprising buildings, land, structures, and monuments gifted to the people of a specific historic burgh. This resource includes: common good map, three new download-to-print zines, audio interviews recorded in 2021-2 with key individuals in the development of the City Observatory, which is a common good site, reopened in 2018 under the custodianship of Collective. The research resource attempts to demystify and expose some of the legal mechanisms and institutional processes around publicly owned ‘common good’ items, and includes contributions from cultural workers who have encountered issues surrounding the common good in their own communities and work.

The zines record the project, and act as a reader and importantly an invitation for further study. The zines include: recorded conversations, previously published articles, and two newly commissioned texts written by Nat Raha and Alison Scott. The zines also hold much of the information presented in Collective’s Library during Summer 2022.

This resource has been created in an attempt to share information on the common good in the spirit of open access and free distribution. In sharing information on the common good, the aim is to connect this particular form of Scottish commons to wider discourses and learning.

Please note that interview transcripts for each grouping of audio tracks can be found in the corresponding zine.

Documentation images taken during ‘A Matter of Precedents’ Study Walks.

View and Download Map

In Summer 2022 a first iteration of the research resource was presented at Collective in the City Observatory Library. It included a study board, a printed map of common good sites in Edinburgh, ​​and an audio library of the recorded interviews.

In May 2022, two in-person walks engaged many collaborators and members of the public to gather around and discuss other common good sites in the city. Walking and talking along two routes in central Edinburgh, the group took in a variety of sites, objects and spaces held in the common good, exploring and imagining forms of custodianship, collective ownership, maintenance, and community use of these sites.

Screenshot 2022 11 25 at 16 46 12

What is common good (in relation to debates on the commons)?

Track 1

> Part 1. Notes on the history of common good in Scotland; in conversation with artist and researcher Simon Yuill, 18.8.2021 (7.25min)

Track 2

> Part 2. Notes on common good and time; in conversation with Simon Yuill, 18.8.2021 (5.19min)

Track 3

> Part 3. Notes on common good and colonialism; in conversation with researcher Emma Balkind, 31.8.2021 (2.21min)

What is Collective’s relationship with the common good?

Push and Pull Towards Common Good

Track 4

> Part 1. Collective’s early research into the relationship between public and private space in Edinburgh; in conversation with Kate Gray, former Director of Collective, 13.8.2021 (12.34min)

Track 5

> Part 2. Collective’s eviction from the previous space at Cockburn Street; in conversation with Kate Gray, former Director of Collective, 13.8.2021 (2.48min)

Track 6

> Part 3. Collective’s search for a non-commercial space; in conversation with Kate Gray, former Director of Collective, 13.8.2021 (15.44min)


How Collective Inhabits the Observatory

Track 7

> Part 1. Director Kate Gray convinces stakeholders that Collective can take over the City Observatory; in conversation with Kate Gray, former Director of Collective, 13.8.2021 (26.38min)

Track 8

> Part 2. The role of the City of Edinburgh Council in activating the common good site on Calton Hill; in conversation with Frank Little, formerly Museums Service Manager at the council, 22.11.2021 (7.54min)

Track 9

> Part 1. Turning an observatory upside down; in conversation with Kate Gray, former director of Collective, (11.50min)

Learning from other struggles and re-imagining possibilities for common good in Scotland

Track 10

> Part 1. Collective’s activation of common good as a precedent; in conversation with Kate Gray, former Director of Collective 13.8.2021 (6.34min)

Track 11

> Part 2. “Common Good has not been tested so much”; in conversation with Frank Little, formerly Museums Service Manager at City of Edinburgh Council, 22.11.2021 (11.15min)

Track 12

> Part 3. Other common good precedents; in conversation with artist and researcher Simon Yuill, 18.8.2021 (14.18)

Track 13

> Part 4. The case of Union Terrace, Aberdeen; in conversation with artist and researcher Emma Balkind, 31.8.2021 (10.52min)