KEYWORDS: Critical

22 March 2016, 6pm


Discussion event with Fiona Anderson, University of Newcastle and Tahl Kaminer, University of Edinburgh; chaired by Siobhan Carroll, Collective.

In his recent book Bad New Days, influential art writer Hal Foster reiterates his melancholic characterisation of contemporary art as ‘post-critical’. He laments that "today 'criticality' is frequently dismissed as rigid, rote, passé, or all of the above." Despite Foster’s assertion, the word ‘critical’, alongside its siblings ‘critique’, ‘criticism’ and ‘criticality’, abounds in art-historical and art-theoretical writing, particularly in the contexts of a renewed interest in the legacies of Institutional Critique.

Likewise, ‘criticality’ is widely cited in institutional contexts. Art students will regularly receive teaching in ‘critical and contextual studies’. Simultaneously, the practice of art criticism is widely observed to have waned in recent years, the role of the critic having been usurped by the figure of the curator. This complex contextual backdrop demands that we seriously consider the term ‘critical’ and its significance to the field of contemporary art. This task is doubly urgent given the widespread suspicion that the word means less than it might initially seem; that it is simply a badge of honour, or a guarantee of political rigour.

This event looked at the word, its history and its contemporary usage in order to establish just what it means for an artistic, curatorial or writing practice to be ‘critical’.


KEYWORDS: Curatorial, Edinburgh College of Art, 8 March 2016, 6pm
KEYWORDS: Value, The Fruitmarket Gallery, 15 March 2016, 6pm

KEYWORDS: A (Polemical) Vocabulary of Contemporary Art is a project led by Victoria Horne and Harry Weeks. Supported by:


This is an archived programme entry.

Thomas Abercromby, John, video still, 2023. Courtesy of the artist. Photo: Daniel Hughes. Featured: Julia Lau and Nevil Jose.

Thomas Abercromby


21 Oct 2023 — 23 Dec 2023

Liza Sylvestre, asweetsea, video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist.

Liza Sylvestre


21 Oct 2023 — 23 Dec 2023